A Bayesian Approach to Cross-Validation in Pedestrian Accident Reconstruction

Paper #:
  • 2011-01-0290

Published:
  • 2011-04-12
Citation:
Davis, G., "A Bayesian Approach to Cross-Validation in Pedestrian Accident Reconstruction," SAE Int. J. Passeng. Cars – Mech. Syst. 4(1):293-303, 2011, https://doi.org/10.4271/2011-01-0290.
Author(s):
Pages:
11
Abstract:
In statistical modeling, cross-validation refers to the practice of fitting a model with part of the available data, and then using predictions of the unused data to test and improve the fitted model. In accident reconstruction, cross-validation is possible when two different measurements can be used to estimate the same accident feature, such as when measured skidmark length and pedestrian throw distance each provide an estimate of impact speed. In this case a Bayesian cross-validation can be carried out by (1) using one measurement and Bayes theorem to compute a posterior distribution for the impact speed, (2) using this posterior distribution to compute a predictive distribution for the second measurement, and then (3) comparing the actual second measurement to this predictive distribution. An actual measurement falling in an extreme tail of the predictive distribution suggests a weakness in the assumptions governing the reconstruction. This paper describes an implementation of these ideas using the Bayesian freeware WinBUGS. A statistical version of a throw distance model was fitted to data from 55 staged collisions between adult pedestrian dummies and sedan-type vehicles, while a standard braking-to-stop model was used to relate skidmark length to vehicle speed. Cross-validation is then illustrated using an additional 15 staged collisions. In 13 of the 15 cases the skidding and throw models yielded consistent results, while in two cases the resulting impact speed estimates were substantially different. In both of the discrepant cases it was possible to identify the sources of the discrepancies, and produce consistency once these were accounted for.
Access
Now
SAE MOBILUS Subscriber? You may already have access.
Buy
Select
Price
List
Download
$28.00
Mail
$28.00
Members save up to 42% off list price.
Share
HTML for Linking to Page
Page URL

Related Items

Book
2008-04-01
Training / Education
2018-08-15
Technical Paper / Journal Article
2009-06-15
Event
2018-04-10
Technical Paper / Journal Article
2013-01-09
Training / Education
2005-08-23
Training / Education
2017-09-06
Book
2004-01-01
Article
2017-07-26